Cheryl Dunlap, the woman charged with embezzling more than $250,000 from a local orthodontist while employed there, waived her formal advisement of charges Wednesday. Her next court date was set for Aug. 19 so her attorney, Tom Silverman, has time to read through the “complex and voluminous” documents associated with the case. Dunlap, 46, worked as a bookkeeper for John Traul Orthodontics in Glenwood Springs for 10 years.
She is accused of writing 111 bogus company checks to herself totaling $252,087.62 between April 1999 and February 2004, the arrest affidavit said. Traul first discovered money was missing from his business in March when he was notified by his accountant that Dunlap was suspected of cashing an unauthorized check against one of the business accounts.”Traul stated that there were several checks signed by Dunlap, and there were also several checks that had been deposited but were not signed,” the affidavit said. Dunlap also might have used a signature stamp to forge some of the checks, the affidavit said. The affidavit said Dunlap admitted to police that she stole the money and she wanted to “make it right.”Dunlap told officers, “Everyone knows that I’m guilty, I did it and that it is time that I admit to it,” according to the affidavit. Traul’s orthodontics business has offices in Glenwood Springs, Carbondale, Basalt and Rifle.
If Dunlap is convicted on both charges, she could face 5 to 15 years in prison.
A former office manager in the dental clinic at 572-bed Albany (N.Y.) Medical Center was sentenced to one to three years in prison for embezzling more than $200,000 during a six-year period. Denise Rossi, 45, also was ordered to pay the hospital $100,000 in restitution.
A tip from another employee first alerted hospital administrators, who conducted a full-scale investigation before turning over their findings to the district attorney, a hospital spokesman said. Rossi, who had check-signing authority, took money paid by patients and insurance companies for dental services. Prosecutors said she used the money for credit card, car insurance and cable bills and car payments, and spent $3,000 to landscape her home. “We’re certainly glad an employee spoke up about this matter. That enabled us to look closely into it,” the spokesman said.
RANGELEY – A federal judge sentenced a Madrid Township bookkeeper Friday to one-year in prison for engaging in a health-care fraud scheme to embezzle nearly $73,000 from her employer.
Lori A. Savage, 34,
the former office manager of Dr. David McMillan’s Rangeley Family
Dentistry, was also ordered to pay $72,956.81 in restitution to the
dental clinic and to serve two years of supervised release after her
Savage diverted funds to pay her own credit card bills and other expenses, according to court records.
She faced up to 10 years in prison and/or a fine of up to $250,000.
States Attorney Paula D. Silsby stated in a release that Savage
received a more lengthy sentence because Savage was found to have abused
a position of private trust and to have used special skill in carrying
out the fraud scheme.
Savage who was paid $13 an hour by
McMillan, also owned her own bookkeeping service and had used some of
the money to buy “very expensive, top of the line computer equipment.”
Court records show that between Feb. 1, 2000 and Oct. 29, 2002, Savage was the officer manager of the clinic.
the authority of her employer Savage prepared and executed 85 checks
from the Franklin Savings Bank account of Rangeley Family Dentistry for
her own personal use in paying credit card bills an other expenses in
her name or the name of a family member.
Savage also made false
entries into the clinic’s computerized ledger to conceal the scheme by
entering payees and items into the ledger that had never been approved
by Dr. McMillan.
Savage also used McMillan’s stamp signature on the checks without the dentist’s permission.
case came to light in November 2002 after McMillan noticed a $1,000
discrepancy in payment to a supplier recorded in his computerized
McMillan brought in his accountant to do an audit.
2000, the accountant found that 37 checks were paid to four different
credit accounts that did not belong to McMillan: Fashion Bug, Capital
One, Universal Card and First Card.
The payments were recorded in
McMillan’s office computer system as expenditures for lab and office
supplies, an affidavit stated.
Silbsy stated in her release that her hope is that the one-year sentence would serve as a deterrent to others who manage clinics and offices for health care professionals in Maine.
KEENE — A North Walpole woman is accused of stealing thousands of dollars from a local dentist.
Fletcher, 28, of 8 Taylor St., North Walpole, is facing up to 15 years
in prison on felony charges of theft by unauthorized taking. Fletcher
was recently indicted by a grand jury convened in the Cheshire Superior
She is accused of taking
payments made to Keene Dentistry and Implants in 2018 while she was an
employee there, keeping the money for herself instead of depositing it
into the business accounts, according to the indictments.
is accused of taking between $1,000 and $1,500 from the business in
August, less than $1,000 in October and more than $1,500 in November.
is charged with class B felony theft by unauthorized taking for August,
class A misdemeanor theft by unauthorized taking for October and class A
felony theft by unauthorized taking for November.
She was also charged with an additional count of class A theft by unauthorized taking for all three months.
Class A felonies carry a possible prison sentence of up to 15 years if convicted.
Fletcher is due in court next week to be arraigned on the charges.
Tina Felshaw of Coeur d’Alene, ID, might be someone to watch out for. Tina, who also sometimes goes by the name Tina Tevebaugh, pled guilty in 2018 in Spokane, WA to felony identity theft.
In a separate offense, Tina was also found guilty in Spokane of felony theft of over $5,000 and was sentenced to 12 months of probation and ordered to make restitution of just under $7,000.
Tina has also had a couple of motor vehicle violations in the years 2014-2015 where, notably, she did not pay the fines assessed and the court had to send them to collection agencies.
Tina declared bankruptcy in 2012 and again in 2015.
Tina has reportedly has worked at several dental offices in the Spokane / Coeur d’Alene area, and we are told that some of her part employment relationships may have ended abruptly.
Tina contacted us by email in August 2019 and asked that her post be removed from our website. Her request implied both that she is still working in the dental field and that her current employer is unaware of her past.
Embezzlement in dental practices has been going on pretty much since dentists began practicing. The following is a case report for an unsuccessful appeal of an embezzlement conviction in 1942. The conviction involved theft of $550, which was probably significant money at that time. The victim was Dr. Robert Kyle, a Los Angeles dentist.
From a judgment of guilty on two counts of grand theft, after trial before the court without a jury, defendant appeals. There is also an appeal from the order denying her motion for a new trial.
The evidence being viewed in the light most favorable to the People, and pursuant to the rules set forth in People v. [65 Cal. App. 2d 570] Pianezzi, 42 Cal. App. 2d 265, 269 [108 P.2d 732], the essential facts are:
Robert S. Kyle, complaining witness, was a practicing dentist in Los Angeles, California, and defendant was his dental assistant. Among her other duties defendant received checks from Dr. Kyle’s patients and kept his books. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation sent Dr. Kyle a check for $300 in payment of dental work. This check defendant endorsed with Dr. Kyle’s name and deposited the amount in her own account contrary to Dr. Kyle’s instructions to deposit the check in his savings account. On another occasion Dr. Zieler gave a check in the sum of $250 to Dr. Kyle for dental services. This check defendant endorsed and cashed without Dr. Kyle’s permission and did not deliver the proceeds thereof to Dr. Kyle.
Defendant relies for reversal of the judgment on two propositions which will be stated and answered hereunder seriatim:
 First: There is not sufficient evidence to sustain the court’s findings that defendant was guilty on two counts of grand theft.
This proposition is untenable. The complaining witness, Dr. Kyle, gave direct evidence sufficient to sustain a finding as to each of the facts set forth above. Conflicting and contradictory evidence must be disregarded by this court. (See People v. Pianezzi, supra.)
 Second: The trial court committed prejudicial error in receiving evidence that in August, 1942, defendant had endorsed three checks which were payable to Dr. Kyle and deposited them in her own account, since the most recent charge of grand theft in the indictment was alleged to have taken place March 12, 1942.
This proposition is likewise untenable. For the purpose of establishing fraudulent intent in a prosecution for grand theft in the nature of embezzlement evidence is admissible of acts of a similar nature committed by defendant before and after the date of the act upon which the conviction is predicated. (People v. Talbot, 220 Cal. 3, 17 et seq. [28 P.2d 1057].)
For the foregoing reasons the judgment and order are and each is affirmed.
The former office manager for a Little Rock dentist was sentenced to
12 years in prison Monday for stealing at least $218,000 from the
practice over a five-year period.
The prison term is symbolic — one year in the penitentiary for each
year Angela Kay Henson worked for Cobb Family Dentistry on Baseline Road
and Dr. Donald Cobb, Pulaski County Circuit Judge Barry Sims said.
He told the 48-year-old Little Rock woman, who had been paid
$42,500 a year, that she had done more than just steal money, but also
robbed Cobb and his wife of their ability to trust and the efforts of
their years of hard work.
“You kind of disgust me,” Sims told Henson before
pronouncing sentence. “They cared for you. You abused their trust. You
took more than just their money. You took their lives as they knew
Henson pleaded guilty last month, and she has repaid Cobb $168,000,
the amount remaining after the insurance reimbursed him. That payment
was a loan from a cousin, she told the judge.
Henson received character endorsements from her pastor, Tommy Jones
of Grace Church, and her husband Andy’s cousin Kyle Jones, who each
described her as being genuinely contrite.
Henson was tearful and apologetic during her eight minutes of
testimony. She denied accusations by the Cobb family that she had
deliberately tried to sabotage the dental practice.
“I am sorry. I never meant to be mean. I never meant to cause you
stress,” she said. “I come from a good family. I raised good kids. I
know Dr. Cobb cared about me … and what I did was wrong. But I wasn’t
The Cobbs have known Henson since she was 19, and over the years have
lent her money when she needed it, such as when her husband was laid
off, according to testimony.
Confronted by prosecutor Sharon Strong, Henson said she could not explain why she stole the money.
“I don’t have a logical reason for that,” Henson told the judge. “I can’t make any rhyme or reason out of that.”
Henson denied Strong’s accusations that she had spent Cobb’s money on
a swimming pool for her home, a trip to New York or a cruise for her
daughter, testifying that she had used other resources for those
Henson faced a 20-year maximum sentence. Her attorney Matthew McKay
asked the judge to consider probation, taking into account her remorse,
the restitution and her lack of criminal history.
Strong requested at least five years in prison, the minimum sentence
for the Class B felony theft, arguing that Henson feels bad about what
she did only because she was caught.
Sims pointed out that the dentist was out substantially more than just the money Henson stole. The cost of the accounting that uncovered the theft was $20,000, while Donald Cobb testified that after Henson was fired, the dentist’s wife discovered about $10,000 in expired insurance checks.
The judge also noted that Henson could have stolen more than
authorities know. Cobb could afford only for a five-year forensic audit,
which allowed for a review of the finances from January 2013 to January
2018 when Henson’s scheme was uncovered.
Henson had been more than an employee; she was also a friend, Donald
Cobb testified. He said he had trusted her absolutely to do a job he
could not do himself — managing the business.
Henson’s thievery was discovered in January 2018 after he decided to
sell his practice because profits had been falling dramatically, he told
“I was working harder than I ever did, and I was making less money than I did 10 years ago,” he said.
He hired an accountant to put together his financial records, but
Henson dragged her feet about providing the requested documents, he
said. Once she did turn over the records, what she had done was obvious,
Cobb told the judge.
“It kind of broke my heart and broke my spirit. I didn’t want to have
a practice anymore,” he said. Cobb did sell the business in November.
Bills were unpaid. Patients had not been billed. Tax penalties were
owed. Cobb described finding 46 pages of insurance claims that had gone
unfiled while insurance checks had not been been cashed.
“It was like there was an attempt to bankrupt my practice,” Cobb told the judge.
His wife, who took over for Henson, also told the judge that Henson’s stealing seemed to be malicious.
“It was just total disorganization,” Margaret Cobb testified. “Ms.
Henson literally caused us so much anguish and put us through hell.”
She said Henson would steal cash payments, but credit patients’
accounts. Henson even stole the rent one tenant paid, Margaret Cobb
She “robbed us of our money … our joy … and also of our trust,” Margaret Cobb told the judge.
Looking for a Prosperident speaker at your next event? Book Now
While the coronavirus has had a dramatic effect on many dental practices, fortunately, we are a geographically dispersed company, with many of our team normally working from their home offices. So we are fully functional and expect to remain so.
We are offering several special programs for practices with cash flow issues caused by the coronavirus; please feel free to CONTACT US for more information.
If you are looking for our Power Hour webinar series, information is HERE.
We wish everyone good health and spirits through this crisis, and please be assured that we are here if you need us.