Joplin, MO Manager Andrea Nikodim gets probation and restitution for $9K Steal from Dental Office

Andrea Nikodim, of Joplin, was arraigned this week on a charge that she stole more than $9,000 from a dental office.

Ms. Nikodim, 33, entered a plea of not guilty Wednesday at her arraignment in Jasper County Circuit Court on a count of felony stealing.

Court records show the charge was filed and a court summons sent to Nikodim on April 9 after an investigation by Joplin police. She has another court hearing on the matter scheduled for Aug. 11.

A probable-cause affidavit states that Joplin police were called Feb. 19 to Joplin Periodontics and Implant Dentistry in the 400 block of South Pearl Avenue regarding a forgery and theft complaint.

Dr. Humaira Habib spoke with the responding officer and provided him with photocopies of nine checks from her dental practice made out to her former office manager, Andrea Slater, who now goes by Andrea Nikodim, according to the affidavit. The checks were written on various dates between March 2019 and March 2020 and were for varying amounts ranging from $502 to $2,500. They added up to $9,121.05.

Andrea Nikodim used signature stamp to forge signatures

Habib told the officer that she had confronted Slater in March 2020 after a training trip she had taken to Arizona about a check she had written herself for $502 using a signature stamp bearing Habib’s name. Habib told the officer that the training fees and trip expenses were to be paid by her office, but Slater could not recall what the additional check covered and promised to pay Habib back.

The affidavit states that she never paid the money back, which led to Habib deciding to dig deeper into office expenditures and her discovery of nine checks she believed were forged by Slater using her signature stamp.

The affidavit states that the defendant, who in the meantime had gone to work for a Joplin chiropractor, became defensive and began calling Habib a liar when confronted about the checks by the officer.

She was arrested in February. But the charge was not filed and the summons sent until April.

Read : ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Want to discuss your practice? Click on the button below.

Related reading: Profiles of Embezzlers – 2 Traits of Those Who Steal Your Money

Update: Suspended Imposition of Sentence, Probation, and Restitution

Jasper County court records (State v. Andrea Nikodim, 21AO-CR00306-01) show the case — a Class D felony charge of stealing $750 or more, investigated by the Joplin Police Department — was resolved with a suspended imposition of sentence. Beginning August 29, 2022, Nikodim was placed on five years of supervised probation and ordered to pay restitution of $9,196.05. Under Missouri’s SIS procedure, no conviction is entered on the public record if probation is completed successfully — a common outcome that leaves future employers with little to find in a standard background check.

More striking: under her former name, Andrea L. Slater, she already had a theft conviction. A 2012 Jasper County case (12AO-CR01151), also investigated by the Joplin Police Department and originally filed as a felony, ended with a guilty plea on January 10, 2013 to misdemeanor stealing — one year in county jail with execution suspended, one year of probation, and 60 hours of community service, all completed by January 2014. The dental practice, in other words, hired someone with an existing theft conviction that a records check under her maiden name would have surfaced. Her civil trail — a 2011 rent-and-possession action, a used-car dealer’s judgment, and a OneMain Financial collection suit filed in October 2024 — rounds out the picture.

Source: Missouri Case.net — State v. Andrea Nikodim, 21AO-CR00306-01 (Jasper County, Circuit 29), reviewed July 2026.